
Dr Jon Finn analyses why Leicester City won the Premier League, covering fixture load, team spirit, self-determination and transformational leadership. He draws out lessons for teams and leaders outside sport.
Not one coach. A whole team of performance psychology coaches, helping you master your three Brain States, every day.
Whether you're a football fan or not, you can't fail to have noticed the coverage of Leicester City this week and their winning of the Barclays Premier League title. And that's the subject of this week's "Tougher Minds" podcast. We spoke once again to Tougher Minds founder and managing director, Dr. John Finn, and he analyzed Leicester's performance throughout the season. And John started by looking at one aspect of Leicester's performance that not many people have commented on, and that was the amount of fixtures they had to play.
And John explained why this might have been a factor in their success. I think, I think what's first of all interesting and hasn't been discussed is the fact that Leicester have played a lot less games than a lot of the tea- well, the teams around them. They have not been in the Champions League, they've not been in European competition. They got knocked out of the domestic cups pretty early. This is significant if we look at data about injury rates, if we play, um, X amount of, uh, game time in a week.
It's significant in keeping the Leicester players fresh and injury-free, if we look at that bigger data piece. I think that's really, really interesting. Um, but it's not just physically fresh, it's psychologically fresh as well. We're increasingly understanding the role of sleep, diet, and exercise, and getting the right levels of those for optimal functioning.
Now, certainly diet and exercise, you would imagine that, um, elite athletes nail that sort of as a normal part of what they do, but there can be over-exercise. You know, there can be imbalances in, in, in nutrition. Um, certainly sleep is not a given. Um, so I, I think that is really worth considering in terms of the success that they've had.
There's a lot of noise in the s- in the media at the moment about Leicester City have got the best sports science support unit in the whole league. I would imagine that every other sports science support unit in the league would contest that, and that what has been reported Leicester do, they all do. So, I think when we're looking at, as a scientist, when we're looking at exceptional levels of performance, what we're looking for is called the main effect variable. What are the things that have had the biggest impact here?
And I think there's a, a lot to be said about their, the game load that they've had. Building on that understanding then, what the lighter game load has allowed them to do, and this is very clear from the data, is use less players. I think Le- Leicester have used the least amount of players, um, of any Premier League team. This is then really important for things that we call team spirit, team bonding, the atmosphere of the group, because every Leicester player has probably played a more meaningful role in that Premier League campaign when you compare them to other, other groups.
Um, so for example, Leicester City from day one of the season have had something to work towards. You know, there, there wasn't a point where they couldn't, um, either secure, first of all, their security in the Premier League, and then it was Champions League places, and then it was the, the league itself. So all those players had a meaningful challenge. Some of the other clubs whose, uh, might have had smaller, smaller squad sizes, sometimes by three-quarters of the way through the season, they can't do anything.
They're just sort of mid, mid-table. They're not going to get relegated, they're not going to get a, a European place, and, uh, you know, the, the league becomes relatively meaningless for them. Um, so I, I think tho- tho- those factors are really important and they need to be considered, and I, I haven't really seen anyone speak about those yet. It, it is interesting. I, I'd like to talk more in detail about the, the team spirit concept, um, uh, uh, later on in the podcast.
But, uh, I'm interested in what you say, uh, and the insight you bring from Tougher Minds about the effect that the fundamentals of sleep, diet, and exercise c- can have that big bearing. And is it perhaps worth people considering things such as airplane flights and travel to and from Europe when you mention the idea of game load and the relative, uh, low game load Leicester City have had in comparison to the, the behemoths of the Premier League in Manchester Citys, Manchester Uniteds, Arsenals, who are involved in, in, in Premier League, uh, and European Champions League, flying to and from heaven knows where week in, week out?
Yeah, definitely. It's real. You know, it's, um... The, the, the, the, the fix- the fixture list is very intense for those teams. Um, that's why it's so difficult to, you know, be consistently successful, as we've seen, that although Man City, Man United, Chelsea have sort of dominated in recent years, they haven't... Any one of those hasn't been able to be consistent in that domination.
You know, look at Chelsea, for example, this season, um, from winning, winning the league quite convincingly to, you know, coming nowhere near this year. So, those late arrivals back in the UK, you know, 3:00, 4:00 in the morning when you've been playing in, in Moscow or somewhere like that, it takes its toll on the body. Um, there's been a, a regime at Leicester where they've had 48 hours recovery after every single game.
You can't do that if you've got a Champions League fixture, uh, two days afterwards. So yeah, I think it's, it's definitely worth paying attention to. And I, and I think unfortunately, the problem of Leicester being so successful this year is that it's gonna make it very difficult for them to be successful next year. Um, because all the advantages they've had that we're talking about, lower game loads, smaller, smaller size squad, every player have a meaningful challenge that erodes when you get into the, the bigger European competitions because they're very demanding.
And also, um, you know, e- even going further in domestic competitions, you know, 1-0 draw in Peterborough on a, or Hartlepool on a, on a Thursday night means you got to go have a replay and then a penalty shootout. You know, these things add up over a period of time, definitely. Yes, I can hear, uh, soccer traditionalists, uh, who bemoan the reduction in FA Cup replays, uh, unhappy, but nevertheless, I'm sure your analysis is absolutely spot on, John.
Yeah. Interestingly then, in the, in the sphere of team spirit, which, um, I think is, is the one refrain I've noticed coming out of the Leicester camp in the aftermath of the, the title win. Uh, there was a period where there was a little bit of a enigmatic response from Claudio Ranieri, the manager. He, he wasn't... I think he even said he didn't know why they'd won the championship. But, uh, I think on Thursday of last week, they staged a press conference and, uh, he, he spoke about team spirit, and I think, uh, he used the English, English word lads, the English colloquialism lads to refer to his squad.
Um, and talked about bringing in, the possibility of bringing in new signings next season, and, and stated quite clearly that any new recruits would have to be... share the same view, the same outlook, the same ethic, team ethic, I suppose, as his, as his current, um, group. And I thought that was significant. Talk to us, if you would then, about how you see the Leicester team spirit, and I think you've touched on it already with the idea of, of people having a meaningful role, but expand on that for us, if you would, please.
Yeah, I think there's, there are some things that we know about, or there's sets of compelling data that suggest certain things are important for team spirit. Having a meaningful goal is certainly one of them. Um, and, and I think that Leicester have had that all the way through their campaign this season.
Again, some teams, they're just working towards avoiding relegation, and, and that's it. And once that, once they reach that, you know, what else can they really achieve? Another thing that seems to fuel team cohesion, team spirit, is success, is winning. And if you look at Leicester's, um, tr- Les- Leicester's performance history back to last season when they had that, you know, great escape, I think they won something like 9 out of 11 games the back end of the season.
Um, they came into the season with a, a kind of a confidence in the squad about that they could perform. So, and, and I, and I think maybe a, a third factor which is really important to balancing sport is they had the right amount of players to facilitate, um, the, the performance sort of on, on the field from a starting 11, but then, you know, there were options on the bench.
And the point I'm trying to make is that every player in that squad had a meaningful role. They haven't had significant injury problems. They haven't had players who were just, you know, consistently sitting on the bench or not in the match day squad. And from my experience working in those environments, that's when things can be problematic, when players are not involved, because they, they start to lead in the wrong way.
Sorry, Andrew, you were gonna say something? Yes. I, I mean, it's probably worth pointing out for listeners that you yourself have worked in, uh, uh, in, as a psycholo- psychology consultant in, um, the Football League in England. So, uh, you do bring that experience as well, which is, which is, uh, certainly adds to the fascination of it. Um, I just wonder, the, the incidents we saw as the season came to a climax with Jamie Vardy possibly losing his cool, and if you listen to some people, with refer- with the referee, and, and being s- uh, suspended for, for that kind of thing.
And Robert Huth, the, the center back as well, perhaps accused of some rather clumsy agricultural tackling. Uh, how does that sort of affect all that, that, that equilibrium of, of, of team spirit, and will, will that be a benefit, would you have thought, to them? I think there's probably two different incidents there. I mean, the Jamie Vardy one is... kind of happens, doesn't it?
People say, "Could he control himself better?" Well, it's very difficult. Um, most of what we do is just an automated response. So, but I think Robert Huth is, you know, really, um, doing something, I think, very purposeful to give himself the best chance of winning that battle with a very physical center forward and laying down his mark.
So, I think both incidents are- Late on in the season enough not to really have too much of an impact. Vardy one could potentially have done that, but I think that the, the league record of Leicester, both from the end of last season and this season, showed that losing one player wasn't gonna massively disrupt their consistency on the field, and that proved to be true.
I think what the Robert Huth, um, incident highlights is that those players were prepared to put their body on the line for each other, and I think that is a hallmark of successful teams. The reality is that sport is a physical contest first and foremost, and it's, you know, certainly field invasion contact sports like, um, football, rugby, these are physical sports, and the first thing you need to do is make sure that you show the opposition you're not scared of them.
And as a collective, if it comes to the crunch, then you're prepared to put your body on the line, uh, more than your opposite number is. So I think that's an interesting part of maybe what Huth, Huth was doing there. And it's interesting hearing commentary from, you know, other physical center forwards in the Premier League saying that, you know, Huth and Wes Morgan were his least favorite players to play against, so it was one, one center forward, because they are so physical, and you're just not gonna bully these guys.
Um, so yeah, I think the, the, the idea that we're going to, you know, put our foot in the tackle, et cetera, et cetera, is a hallmark of very good teams. And if you look at any, any good football team, that's typically what they did first, whether it was the great Leeds United teams or the, the, the great Man United teams. Um, yeah, so that, that would be my take on that.
Yeah, the, uh, the names Roy Keane and, and Billy Bremner perhaps, uh, spring to mind, um, around that. Um, I just wonder then, if someone's looking from the outside, would you say that, that the language of Claudio Ranieri is very... almost suggests an intimacy with the team and, uh, talks about his lads and the lads. Do you think that that validates then the view that there is this, this sense of, of meaning for all of them, that they all share?
They have a very, very well-developed sense of that, would you say? I think it's more developed now they've won the league. You know, stories are very important for people. We are social. Um, stories seem to be the glue that help us to share our experiences. So now the Leicester team have a story which seems to... which is being talked about as if it's unparalleled. So their team cohesion, their team efficacy and esteem must be at the highest level it's been.
And I think Ranieri wants to play on that in order to secure, um, his, his players, um, that have done so well for him this year. He doesn't want to see them go off to, to other places. And he's been clever, isn't he? He's presented another meaningful challenge, which is doable. He's saying, "Just give me one more year." He's not saying, "Spend the rest of your life here. Just give me one more year." And you don't know what's going to happen, do you, after that year?
They might win something else, and you don't know who they'll sign in the summer. So I think Ranieri is very... although, although he couldn't explain, um, psychological theories, he's certainly got a good understanding of how people tick, if you like, and he's using every trick in the book to try and, um, secure the loyalty of the players that he wants to keep this year.
Because if he keeps the players, he's got the best chance of, of him doing a better job. Yeah, it's, uh, it's interesting already the, the machinations of the multimillion-pound football industry are already, um, showing themselves. I noticed a report the other day about Riyad Mahrez's agent, uh, you know, do-doing the classic, "Well, um, you know, it's 50/50 whether he's going to stay. Uh, he does have offers from elsewhere, and, um, they are very good offers."
So whilst ever, um, people might point to a totally committed bunch of individuals, uh, there are no doubt external pressures and imperatives on them to, um, look after their own bank accounts, which, uh, is, is probably, I would imagine, pretty persuasive, especially in a, a short career such as professional sport. But you think then that, that Claudio Ranieri's reframing of a new challenge and, and the, the descriptions and the way he's presenting that is, is, uh, is him trying to react to these, these external distractions, these external problems and issues and, and, and go again for next season?
Yeah. I, I think Ranieri gets the idea of self-determination. So the idea that people are more inclined to do something if they have a say in it, and at some level, that might make that thing more, more enjoyable, um, easier to do. So he's not telling his players, "You must, uh..." He's giving them a choice, but he's trying to influence their decision, um, which is a clever tactic because when you start coercing people, then that's when they do the opposite thing that you want them to do.
You know, this guy is... he's not naive, is he, to the world of football and management? I think he was probably last managing in England probably 16 years ago or something. So, and he's had substantial experience before and during that period of time, you know, since, since he left England. So yeah, he's... that's what I would say he's doing. He's giving them the choice, but, um...
But he's painting a very clear picture of why they want to be staying here. Um, yeah, and I think he's-- what he's saying is very credible. You know, you don't-- if you go to another team, you don't know where you'll, you'll fit in. You know, you go to another team for a big transfer fee, and we've seen it lots of times, players can't handle that pressure. They only got-- get given a couple of opportunities. They might get an injury. All of a sudden, they're with a new backroom staff, a new sports science team.
Their approach might not fit, you know, that player. So there are lots of variables which can stop you from being successful, you know, in a, in a transfer. I, I want to talk in a, in a moment about how, how other people can learn from Leicester, if you like, and how people away from the sporting sphere might be able to bottle what they've got and, and use it for their own lives and their own goals that they have and, and help their own performance. But I just wonder if you had a reflection briefly on two elements of the Leicester story that are quite well, quite well known by many and, and seem to me to be fascinating examples of, of how people can turn themselves around.
Jamie Vardy, we've already talked about. The, the free-scoring center forward is likely to be selected for England in the European Championships this summer. Scored a fantastic goal against, uh, in a friendly international against Germany. Um, I could even see that, and I'm no great soccer connoisseur. And then the other guy we mentioned, Riyad Mahrez, um, uh, I think a Frenchman of Algerian extraction, um, playing in the French Second Division. Jamie Vardy, of course, before he was a Premier League player, I think has played for any number of, of, of conference teams, non-league teams, worked his way up into the Premier League.
I mean, what does-- what-- how do you reflect on those, uh, what might be termed rags to riches stories of those two guys? Well, I think it, it, it fits with what the science says about development of, of human skills, is that the more we practice, the better we get. And actually, or the more of the right practice we do, the better we get. And actually, you know, young men's brains aren't fully developed till we're, on average, 25.
So, we're seeing two players who've clearly good footballers, means they've been exposed to, um, lots of good football practice through their childhoods and teenage years. Probably got some genetics which are helpful as well. But actually, staying in the lower leagues has allowed both players to accumulate, um, lots and lots of, of live match, uh, practice.
You know, actually playing in leagues, playing, uh, with pressure on you and, and testing your skills. Whereas what often happens in the elite academies, it's very hard for young players to get good game time, and they end up dropping out of the game very quickly. Um, so I, I guess staying in the lower leagues, to an extent, has helped Jamie Vardy and the, the other fella to, um, accumulate, uh, good quality practice.
So, in a way, what they've done is what we would expect would happen. However, it's not the norm of the industry, because talent, um, in football and lots of other sports isn't so much about... There isn't a belief system that, uh, if you keep practicing, you will get better, and practice is the vehicle to future success. It's more viewed as what you can do now is going to determine whether you can be successful in the future or not.
And they're very-- they might sound subtle differences, but they're very different. Um, if you, if you're in a, in an academy and you're 18, and someone looks at you and says, "Well, you're not good enough. You're not gonna be good enough to be, um, a professional footballer when you're 24." That's nonsense because no one can predict how good someone will be in six years, uh, without seeing what they're like in six years with the practice that they've done, if, if that kind of makes sense.
Yeah, certainly. I think, uh, there, there's certainly a, a big interest in talent development, isn't there now, by the FA, and they could do a lot worse than listen to this and, and, um, really keep in mind, I think, that very, very clear lesson, uh, very clear message you're giving about the, the, uh, hard work pays off and, and, and practice pays off. So, um, yeah, fascinating to see Jamie Vardy and Riyad Mahrez progress as they have done, and it'll be equally as fascinating to see if, uh, Jamie Vardy can carry on that form through to, uh, the England team in the European Championships this summer.
I'm sure many England fans certainly hope so. John, how then can people outside of sport, how can people who don't have performance support teams behind them, sports science teams behind them, performance science teams, if you like, then behind them, how can they benefit? Is there anything they can learn from Leicester City's success? Are there any simple takeaway lessons and messages from, from the way that they've defied the odds and succeeded?
Yeah, I think there are, you know, there are a few. The, the first one, I think, is you need a meaningful goal in your life. You need something to work towards. Um, Jamie Vardy wouldn't become, have become the footballer that he is if he didn't have his big goals of, you know, being a Premier League footballer, playing for England. You know, his, his, uh, his skills would have stopped. We call it arrested development in the, the world of motor control.
So his, his skills wouldn't have progressed to the level they are. The reason he's got to where he is now is because he's kept working, he's kept going, he's kept going. The reason that Leicester, or one of the, I believe, the main reasons Leicester were able to win the league is the fact that they, they set out, um- ... clear, uh, timeline and checkpoints throughout the season that they're working towards. First, they're working towards getting 40 points to stay safe in the league, and then they're working towards probably Champions League places, and they're working towards, you know, winning the league, and they're setting that out clearly.
Um, but also keeping focusing on, on one game at a time in the process. Let's just make sure that we all fulfill our roles and responsibilities in every game. So I think if you want to be successful in life, you need to have a big goal that's meaningful to you. Um, you might have several big goals that are meaningful to you. Having that makes it a lot easier to push yourself every day and to not fall into the sort of procrastination habits that homo sapiens are ultimately designed to, to do.
So that's one thing. I think what we can take away from Leicester is an insight into team spirit and the power of it. If you get a team working together in the right way, how much value can be added. And, you know, I've, I've seen that firsthand in a team that I worked for. It wasn't... We didn't win the Premier League, because we weren't in the Premier League, but we certainly punched way above our weight in terms of the money that we were spending on players.
This is a football story, on players and salaries compared to the teams around us. And the role of, I guess, psychological safety, which is a kind of a common term in, in, um, in psychology about group, group performance. And psychological safety seems to be a main effect variable in teams performing well or not.
You know, team members feeling safe in the group, that they can air their views, that they can, you know, have an equal say, that they can play a meaningful role in, in the performance of the group. I think we can see a lot of those characteristics in the, in the Leicester team. But I think all of those things actually come back to, or are underpinned by having transformational leaders. So if you want to have a successful team, you need to have transformational leaders.
These are people who are, you know, role models. They do all the right things. So they behave like professionals, um, athletes, if it's a Leicester City case. You know, they're always wearing the right attire. Um, they set the right example in the way they live their life and what they eat and how they train and how they, you know, sleep even.
They lead from the front. They're, they're kind of vocal, and they give that vibe when, off when they walk in the room. But equally, they're very good at talking to their, their teammates, you know, bringing people on and listening to them and allowing them to have an input. Um, and being able to coach, you know, some of the less experienced members of the squad in a way that really brings them on, that allows them to not get too caught up in things that aren't going too well for them, but also pay close attention to, um, the things that they're doing well.
You know, so I, I think transformational leaders, and I, and we can-- I think we can see a number of those people in the Leicester squad. Robert Huth, I think, would be an example. He's not really been mentioned. I think he won, or Chelsea certainly won two league titles whilst he was signed at that club. He's certainly, he's certainly an experienced player, isn't he? As you say, what- whatever the- Yeah. -the stats say, he's, he's certainly got, got the runs on the board. You see, um, Kasper Schmeichel, I think, is always sort of older than his years, and obviously the influence that his father and his father's experience would have had, had on him.
You see Jamie Vardy, I think, has got a lot of leadership qualities. He could probably be quite a bad leader, I would imagine, but I think in, in this case, his, his leadership qualities have really been galvanized, and, you know, he's probably brought a belief, a sense of belief to that team that they can achieve. Uh, Wes Morgan seems to be a kind of chap who's, who's a strong leader. Uh, I think Ranieri is as well.
It sounds like some of the members of the backroom staff are. So you've got some, you know, key people in place to really facilitate those roles and, and bring the group together. So I, I think what lessons can people learn in a nutshell? You need meaningful challenges, challenges in your life. You know, one of the, the areas that we work in a lot is, is education, and often kids are disengaged at school because schoolwork's stopped being, being meaningful to them.
They just check out, and they spend their days at school messing about and not actually doing, not paying attention to their work. Secondly, I think from a team dynamic perspective, um, don't underestimate the role of transformational leaders in your group. Don't underestimate the role of trying to create a self-determining environment. You know, um, being coercive and bullying people isn't that helpful.
One of, one of the things that amazed me with Alex Ferguson, having been someone who's followed that stuff quite closely, something that I didn't know until I read his book, or read something about him, was that, yeah, he's got this fierce reputation, and he'd tell players when they needed to be told. But he also, before every game, spoke one-to-one in his office with every member of his first team squad, explaining, one, if they're in the team, why they're in the team, and what their roles and responsibilities were that day.
And two, if they weren't in the team, why not, and what they needed to do that week in order to give themselves a better chance of getting in the team. And that might sound, sound like common sense, but it's not common practice in football management, I guarantee you, um, for different reasons. One is it takes a lot of time to do that. But I think if we look through the history of successful people and certainly successful teams, we see these transformational characters, uh, transformational leaders, and they're absolutely essential, um, if you want to have team success.
You know, and the good news is you can learn how to do, how to, how to do this stuff. You know, leadership isn't a natural talent. I've worked with some of the best leaders in the world in their sports, and they know that they can get better at leadership. They're the first to admit it. They're not just natural leaders. Um, they've practiced at what they do, you know, so we can, we can all get better at these things with practice. Thanks for listening to the Habit Mechanic podcast.
If you liked it, please subscribe and tell someone else about one of the ideas or insights that you found most interesting.
