
Dr Jon Finn looks at Naomi Osaka's withdrawal from the 2021 French Open and argues it shows mental resilience. He explains what press conferences may do to the brain under scrutiny and how thinking habits can be rebuilt.
Not one coach. A whole team of performance psychology coaches, helping you master your three Brain States, every day.
Hi, everyone. Welcome to another Tougher Minds podcast. My name is Dr. John Finn. I'm actually in our, uh, head office in Leeds. And yesterday, I was speaking on the radio about Naomi Osaka and her decision to leave the French Open, which was connected to her not wanting to speak in post-match press conferences. So, I thought that would be a good topic for this podcast, just to explore what, what we were thinking about on that, on that radio interview that I was doing, and to explore the, the challenges that I think everyone is, is going through at the moment, and I think just the challenges of the modern world and
how that can lead us to spending an awful lot of our time thinking about things that are not helpful for us. So, as always, the gist of our podcast is about becoming a habit mechanic, and anyone who wants to become a habit mechanic can take the, the free course, which you can access through the Tougher Minds website. Um, but let's go back to Naomi Osaka. One of the really interesting things about Naomi is that she's only 23 years old, and just for those who, who don't know her, she, since 2018, she's now won four majors in tennis.
23 years old, reportedly this year earned already 55 million dollars. What I take away from that is a young lady that has an awful lot of attention on her, and possibly in a way that no other female professional tennis player has experienced before. Because if we think of some of the other modern greats, like a Serena Williams, when they were at that y- that age, the intensity of social media wasn't there, and the intensity of, of the current state of social media means that Naomi's life is being dissected almost
24/7 in a way that no one has ever experienced before. So, I think that's the context that we have to understand what Naomi is going through, and we can all appreciate that because we all live in, in the same world where we have these, this constant ability to be scrutinized and commented on and, and to also do that to other people through mediums like social media.
Now, the specifics of, of what actually happened in this current episode for Naomi was that she said that she didn't want to, in the French Open, take part in the post-match interviews because she didn't feel that was helpful for her. The tournament and other tournaments and federations responded to that by saying, "Well, you must.
This is a, this is an obligation that, that we expect you to do. It's part of your contractual obligation." And Naomi's response to that was to say, "Well, okay, I'm gonna pull out of the tournament, and I'm gonna take some time away from the sport and from playing professional tennis." And what unraveled then was Naomi explaining how, since she'd won that first major in 2018, that she has suffered bouts of what she described as, as depression, and she wasn't, she's not feeling great about herself, essentially.
So, why then is the press conference piece potentially problematic for her? Well, the way that I would understand it is that if we think about Naomi's brain, like any of our brains, we have the lighthouse in our brain, and this is how, this is the simplest way we can ex- we, we can explain the brain, and this is how we do it at Tougher Minds. Imagine you've got a lighthouse in your brain. There are two characters that live in the brain.
One's called Hugh. Hugh stands for horribly unhelpful emotions. The other character is called Wilhelmina Power, or Willpower for short. Hugh operates the lighthouse control center. That means it uses the beam of, of light from the lighthouse to scan and search the environment. And the first thing it instinctively looks for are threats, problems, criticisms, mistakes.
Could be mistakes, threats, problems from the past, the present, or even into the future. And Willpower's role is to help Hugh to get its attention back onto things that are more helpful for us doing well. And what I would see is happening for Naomi in the press conferences is that it really gets her Hugh paying attention to lots of unhelpful things, things that linger for far longer than the period of, of, of the press conference, thoughts that she just can't shake, she can't get rid of, and maybe what then spills into social media afterwards.
And what this really is, is Naomi is, is reporting that she's developed lots of unhelpful thinking habits, that she is getting fixated onto thoughts about worries and threats, criticisms about her, that she just can't shake because Hugh is magnetized to them. And the press conference is a trigger for that.
So there's, there's commentary about Naomi being selfish and things like that, which I think is a nonsense because this is Naomi's experience of, of her life, and, and only she can report really what goes on inside her head. And she's saying that, "These things make me feel so terrible about myself that I just don't want to even go there anymore."
And I would say that Naomi walking away from the tournament in the manner that she has is a sign of her being resilient. Because the way that I understand it and the way that the, the science understands it is that resilience is, it's a two-part concept. The first concept is being aware enough to understand that you're doing things and you're thinking things that are not helpful for you being at your best.
And that's what she's recognized with this situation. And the second part of being resilient is to do something that's gonna get your attention onto and to help you to do more things that allow you to be at your best. So she's removed herself from the situation. So in part, Naomi is showing us that she is a habit mechanic, that she's working on herself. But what she now needs is to put the same dedication and commitment into rebuilding her thinking habits in the context of the criticism that is-- that comes her way because of, of, of, of the profession
that she's in. Not that that's right, but that's just what is happening currently, and it, and it's very tough, uh, for, for professional athletes. She needs to, to work on herself to build better thinking habits. Because ultimately, she's gonna play professional tennis. That criticism kind of comes part and parcel. And the way that I would think about this for Naomi is that she's on a continuum in her ability to deal with that criticism at the moment.
And this continuum, think of one end is that she would be perfect at dealing with this criticism. The other end would be she wouldn't be able to deal with it at all. So one end might be a 10, where she's perfect. The, the other end might be a zero. And Naomi now is somewhere on this continuum. I don't, I don't know where she is. Maybe she's at the lower levels. Maybe she's higher than we appreciate.
Maybe she's just going through a really bad patch in her life right, right now, and the, the stress of a, of a press conference is just another thing that, that just makes, that just is almost the straw that breaks the camel's back. But she's somewhere on this continuum. Wherever Nomi-- Naomi is at, she can learn skills that she can turn into habits to make it easier for her to get better at dealing with the challenges that come about through scrutiny and criticism, including those that, that come and, and are often sparked in, in press conferences.
So she's removed herself from the environment, which is great. She's recognized that there's a problem here, and no doubt she's got to do some recuperation and get that brain working properly again. Because if she's been experiencing depression, her brain probably isn't working particularly well, so she needs to rehabilitate it with the basics of good sleep, good diet, good exercise, and all those fundamental things we talk about at Tougher Minds. But then she needs to start learning some, some, in very broad sense, resilience skills to allow her to build better thinking habits.
What we also have to recognize, and I mentioned this very deliberately earlier, is that Naomi is only 23. And from what we understand about brain maturation, it means that the parts of Naomi's brain that allow her to deal with, uh, criticism are not fully developed yet. So what happens with our brains is that they wire from the back to the front.
So the parts of the f-- the parts of the brain we deal with to regulate HUE, our horribly unhelpful emotions, or the limbic regions of our brain, they're not fully wired until we're in our mid-20s. So Naomi's still developing the hardware, if you like, to allow her to, to deal with these challenges. So I think Naomi's future is very bright, and she'll look back on this episode in years' time and recognize that it really helped her to develop herself as a, as a, as a person and as a, and as a better professional athlete.
Uh, at least I hope that, I hope that is the case. But what she's achieved so far in her life, it tells us she's a very resilient person. Resilience is contextual, um, and being resilient in a, in a press conference under the pressure of real magnified scrutiny is different to the sort of resilience you might need, you know, to win a tight set in a, in a major, uh, tennis final.
But Naomi can, can develop the resilience skills required to get better at dealing with, with, with the criticism, and she can learn to overcome these thinking problems that she's got. And we do wish her all the best on, on that journey. So I, I just wanted to give a, a different insight into a big story in the press and for one of the most promising athletes on the planet, and, you know, wish her, wish her, wish her good luck.
But I do think she's, she is a habit mechanic. Uh, but like all of us, we can all learn to become better habit mechanics. And anyone who wants to do that, remember you can access the Habit Mechanic course free of charge, uh, on our website. If you like the podcast, guys, please do subscribe to it. Then we can remind you every time we release a new episode, which we do regularly. The last thing I'd like to say is, if you want to be more resilient, just do a very simple exercise.
Give yourself a score out of 10 for how well you did to be at your best in the last 24 hours or so far today. 10 would mean you were perfect, 1 would mean you failed. Once you've given yourself a score, just write down one simple and practical thing you can do in the next period of time to make your life a little bit easier.
It might be going for that five-minute walk that you've kept thinking about but never done. It might be eating a piece of fruit instead of a chocolate bar. It might be having a decaf instead of a, a full caffeinated drink. It might be making sure that you get to bed 15 minutes earlier tonight. But by doing this, we're starting to develop and refine and tune up our resilience muscles.
And we get good at what we practice, guys. So if we want to be habit mechanics, we need to be practicing these tiny little things every day. And again, you can learn more about that in the Habit Mechanic course. Until next time, guys, stay safe and well. And remember, you're only one tiny habit away from achieving your goals. Thanks for listening to the Habit Mechanic podcast.
If you liked it, please subscribe and tell someone else about one of the ideas or insights that you found most interesting.
