
Dr Jon Finn argues that leadership is a science, using criticism of England's cricket selection as an example. He says applying it matters for teams adjusting to hybrid working after the Covid-19 pandemic.
Not one coach. A whole team of performance psychology coaches, helping you master your three Brain States, every day.
Hi there. This is Dr. John Finn. Welcome to another Tougher Minds podcast. I'm out walking again, and I'm just reflecting on some of the discussions around the England-India test series that's going on at the moment. You may be aware that, um, England's selection criteria is being analyzed, and in some quarters criticized, because they're rotating their players and having to manage what's quite a challenging situation with players being in this bubble, uh, to obviously prevent COVID spreading, and then having to spend periods of time in quarantine as they're transitioning in and out of the bubble.
And I just think it's a really interesting discussion because some of the criticis-- And I-- Well, let's step back actually for one second. I think we all have to bear in mind that what is maybe England's goal, uh, in this, in this particular test series is a little bit different from other test series in that although they obviously want to prioritize winning the games, they've got to balance it out with player welfare and player well-being, and that's obviously very challenging.
Um, so I don't really want to criticize any-anything that anybody's doing. I just want to observe what some of the discussions around what's going on. And one thing that I think is really interesting is that England's approach is being critiqued as being too scientific from some quarters. And I can completely understand why people would say that. But actually, I think, in, in my opinion and what I know about science, if anything, it's not scientific enough.
And what I mean by that is that I think, um, people are observing that England are using data information about player fitness levels and, you know, the age of players and, and some-sometimes protecting players, um, from, from a fitness perspective, from a well-being perspective. But I don't think that all scientific analysis is being used.
Uh, the England team could go much further and use what I would call leadership science, which is a combination of, um, behavioral science, psychology, and neuroscience. And if they're u-- or if we use that science, it would tell us that actually what England are doing is disrupting their chances of winning test matches. And I'm sure they're completely, completely aware that rotating players in and out of the squad is making it more difficult for them to win games.
But I don't think that the, the, the commentary around these challenges is actually accepting that leadership, that team dynamics is just as much of a science as the fitness side, uh, as the well-being side is. So I just think that's really interesting that still we, we are not really understanding that leadership is a science and that we can use scientific insights to actually help us to develop better leaders, to be better leaders, use scientific insights to help our teams to work more efficiently and effectively.
And this is gonna be absolutely crucial if we want to tr- make a really successful transition out of the, the COVID situation and into, if we switch away from cricket now and professional sport, into people's normal lives, which is probably gonna be moving for a lot of people into a hybrid work situation where they're not anymore going to be in the office every day, uh, being face-to-face with their colleagues.
And that's really gonna make it much more difficult for, for teams to function really well. So, in order to make the transition to this hybrid working situation less challenging, we do need to harness leadership science. And first of all, we need to recognize that it is a science and that we can use, um, qualitative, quantitative sets of compelling data to actually inform our decisions about how we influence people's behavior and also how we influence our own behavior.
And for me, that's what leadership's about. It's a two-sided coin. Uh, the first part of it is, how well can I influence my own behavior? And we can use science to do that. And the second part of it is, what can I do to influence other people's behavior? And we can, of course, use science to do that. And on the former note, influencing our own behavior, this is why we've created the MePower Resilience Planner, because we know lots of people are struggling right now to actually manage themselves, and they're feeling overwhelmed, and they're feeling tired, and they're feeling a bit burned out.
But what the MePower Resilience Planner shows you, and it's absolutely free, is that there are loads of tiny little things that we can do to make it easier for us to be at our best more often. And the planner structures this on a, on a daily and weekly basis. It's giving you some really simple, practical things that you can do that are, that are based in really cutting-edge science that make your life easier. And already people are reporting the benefits of, of using that tool, which is, which is really great.
And you, you can access it. It's absolutely free. Just go to our website, and you'll be able to, uh, download it there. So, that's just my quick reflection, guys, on a little piece of news that keeps reoccurring, is that the England cricket team's approach is too scientific, and I don't think that quite reflects what's going on. If we, if we really, if we really wanna talk about science in human behavior, we have to accept leadership is a science.
Um, and therefore, what, what they're doing isn't, isn't too scientific at all. Arguably, it's not scientific enough. But the challenge they've got is that their job at the minute isn't just to win test matches, it's to look after player well-being. We're gonna keep pushing out, uh, very similar podcasts to this, guys. Short, sharp insights that hopefully help you and your teams, uh, to be at your best more often. So, if you want to get easy access to those, just subscribe to the podcast, and you'll be made aware as soon as the next one becomes available.
Again, if you want to get access to the free planner, if you wanna give your colleagues access, just visit the website, and you'll find it there. If you've got any questions, get in, get in touch via the website, and, and we will endeavor to answer those as quickly as we can. Thanks for listening, and I'm looking forward to speaking to you again on the next podcast. Thanks for listening to the Habit Mechanic podcast.
If you liked it, please subscribe and tell someone else about one of the ideas or insights that you found most interesting.
