The Habit Mechanic podcast
THE HABIT MECHANIC PODCAST
14 Jan 2026 · 39 minMotivationSleep, Diet & Exercise

Why Willpower Isn’t a Myth — and Why Habits Really Matter in the AI Era

Dr Jon Finn and Andrew Foster of Tougher Minds respond to an article calling willpower a myth. They argue that willpower is the means of changing habits, and that habits sit at the centre of any lasting change, including weight loss.

0:0039:28
CHAPTERS
Also on
START FOR FREE

Your own coaching team, helping you achieve more.

Motivation

Not one coach. A whole team of performance psychology coaches, helping you master your three Brain States, every day.

1Take your AI-Edge Assessment
2Work with your coaching team

In this episode

  • Dr Jon says the nature-versus-nurture framing is out of date, because what we practise shapes us and even genes are malleable through epigenetics.
  • Willpower is described as the conduit for change: a limited resource used to interrupt old habits and build replacement ones.
  • Environment, sleep, stress and who you spend time with all shape eating and exercise, so changing habits works better when planned in advance.
  • Willpower is tied to high-charge Brain States, which depend on sleep, exercise and nutrition, and building such habits matters more in the AI era.

Full transcript

About 5,500 words · tap a time to jump the player there

Meet Andrew Foster And His Coaching

Hello, Habit Mechanics, Dr. John Finn here. I hope you're having a great week so far. So today we're doing something a little bit different. I'm excited to have a guest, and we're joined by our head of coaching, tougher minds head of coaching, Andrew Foster. Now I've known Andrew for a very long time, and we've worked together for going on 15 years now.

Um Andrew is our head of coaching, and I'll let him say a few lines about what he actually does at Tougher Minds in case you've never met him before or heard from him.

Thanks, John. Great to be on the podcast. Yeah, so I'm Andrew Foster. Uh the book of my works with fantastic people in all sorts of different sectors, uh, all sorts of different stages of their careers. They they tend to be super ambitious, really, really exciting people who can see that gap between what they intend to do and what actually ends up happening.

Um what I help them do is is close that close that gap. Um, so uh it's it's it's brilliant work to do, it's really rewarding, and it's great to be here on the podcast to discuss uh our work together.

Yeah, one of the things I find really interesting about your work, Andrew, is how many people renew with you. So they normally sign up for like a two-month program, don't they? Four one-to-ones over two months, but then they they continue working with you. And it's what's often not just surprising but delightful about that is lots of these people you're working with, they're not slouches in the sense of they're actually quite exceptional people in what they've achieved.

And that doesn't mean that you need to be an outstanding top of your professional person to work with you, but the people who everyone else looks at and thinks, well, they've got it, they've got this sorted out, they don't need any support, but they're actually they're often the ones who are most minded to get the support

Why High Performers Seek Ongoing Coaching

because they understand the value of um just having an expert to keep touching base with to help them overcome the challenges that we all have, that just sometimes it seems like some people don't have those challenges because they're they're doing super well.

Absolutely. I think a lot of the time um the challenges we can we can reframe them as actually getting after opportunities in the in the best way that we can. So when someone has some success with us uh working working together in that first two months, then very often that then leads to right, what's next? I've now because I did X, I've now got this opportunity to do Y, and I understand that I will be more likely to hit my straps and really hit my potential on achieving why if I'm doing um taking the same approach and developing it and getting even better at using uh tougher mind strategies and tougher mind tools to manage how I'm working towards that new goal.

And one of the, and this brings us on to what we're going to talk about in this podcast, one of the side effects of um, and I've seen this in my own work, and Andrew tells me about this all the time. One of the side effects of putting the tougher minds uh program into practice that is becoming a habit mechanic working on your brain states is that people lose weight, and it's very rarely something that we are primarily focusing on.

But Andrew and I were just talking about this before Christmas that um people that he's doing one-to-one coaching with, one of the things that they keep talking about is that they're losing weight. I actually had an incident um in the last 12 months where someone had booked some coaching with me, but

Your own coaching team, helping you achieve more.

The Surprising Side Effect: Weight Loss

they'd sort of deliberately done it into the future. So I hadn't seen this person for say six months. And when I saw them on the call, I didn't recognise them. I was thinking, as I'd only ever met them once before online, I was thinking, is this the same person? And then the person disclosed that they'd been using the diet, exercise, sleep, swap plant, and they'd lost a couple of stone or something.

But we've we're in January, and often people are resetting what they want to be working on, they're renewing their goals, and one of the obvious things that people talk about is weight loss, and we came across an article in a very prominent prominent media outlet that you will know. Um, and we thought that it was uh outdated in how it was thinking about weight loss, and we thought it was a good um good thing to talk about.

And the the the title of this article is The Myth of Willpower and Why Some People Struggle to Lose Weight More Than Others, and uh this really is a story about uh why some people struggle to change to change their behavior because that's what weight loss is really all about, but it's uh saying you know, willpower is pretty useless, really, and we keep hearing that message, but what I know after 25 years of studying these things in great detail is that it's not, and willpower is getting a massively bad rap, and it's getting a misinformed rap.

So today we want to sort of demystify how we actually change our behaviour, including the things that we might need to do to lose weight, um, and come at this with a with a robust

Debunking The Willpower Myth

strategic scientific lens. Because understanding how to lose weight, just like understanding how to stop beating yourself up as much as you currently are, it is you can think we we now have the same level of understanding that we would need if we wanted to fix a car engine, hence the habit mechanic, and it's about habits ultimately. So, when you read this article, Andrew, what were the main kind of jarring points for you?

Or you might want to, as a as someone who set out from Cambridge University wanting to have a career in journalism, you might want to even step back further and uh frame the article for us.

Well, there's like I'm I'm just looking, just double checking for myself again. There's one this is a very long article. There's a single mention of the word habit in the whole in the whole um article where that should be a central central point of it. You know, I I what's good about the article is that um clearly it's quite a lot of legwork being put into it.

They they've gone out the journalist has gone out and talked to a lot of different people and seems genuinely interested and try to provide some good detail, but that if you're not putting habits at the core or you know at the centre of the piece, then you are not going to be able to inform the people who read it uh as to what you're setting out to do uh at the start.

Um so so yeah, that would be my that would be my main my main observation uh in the in the first um instance.

So essentially the article is very much leaning towards the nature side of the nature-nurture argument, that is we are a result, we as human beings are a result of this used to be the debate, either our genetics, which is nature, or we are a result of our environments, which is nurture. Fast forward to 2026 and even you know, fast forward to the early 2000s, we know that that argument is hogswash and it's way is you know, it's lit, it's it's at least 20 years out of date.

And this article, therefore, is at least 20 years out of date in terms of what science actually tells us about why people end up in the situation they're in, whether that's overweight or worrying too much, or being the exact weight they want to be, and and thinking in a really helpful, healthy way. So if we just go to the basics, what science has shown us,

Ready to perform at your best?

Start for free, take your assessment, start working with your coaching team