The Habit Mechanic podcast
THE HABIT MECHANIC PODCAST
9 May 2025 · 13 minMotivationFocus & Productivity

Coaching Is Failing in the AI-Era: 4 Reasons Why

Dr Jon Finn explains why traditional talk-therapy-based coaching often fails to deliver lasting change, and how a four-step success cycle built on Brain States, strategic planning and habit automation addresses those gaps.

0:0013:19
CHAPTERS
Also on
START FOR FREE

Your own coaching team, helping you achieve more.

Motivation

Not one coach. A whole team of performance psychology coaches, helping you master your three Brain States, every day.

1Take your AI-Edge Assessment
2Work with your coaching team

In this episode

  • Dr Jon cites studies of over 52,000 people suggesting CBT can be shown to help only one in five, with benefits fading within about 12 months.
  • Traditional coaching rarely starts from how the brain works, so the success cycle begins by measuring your Brain States.
  • Disconnected tips and tricks are quickly forgotten without a long-term and a daily strategic plan, which the Task Director and Day Designer systems provide.
  • Lasting change needs habits automated using the nine action factors, rather than relying on a single behavioural science idea.

Full transcript

About 1,900 words · tap a time to jump the player there

Amazing Client Results with AI System

Hello Habit Mechanics . It's Dr John Finn here I am doing a walking podcast on my way into the office this morning . I've been astounded by some of the results that our coaching clients are getting with our new human AI performance psychology structure . They're consistently just getting these amazing results , and often highly tangible , like securing $90,000 pay rises , being given equity in businesses because they're now seen as leaders in human ai performance .

So we've been reflecting on well , why is that ? Why is this ? Why ? Why is the system we're teaching getting such good results ? And I think for me I have to go back to the beginning , which is why did I create tougher minds ? Why did I create the habit mechanic ? Why did I extend that in the AI era to the habit mechanic AI edge system ?

Sorry , I'm walking up a hill , so I'm slightly of breath . So it's because broadly what I got taught at university and I've got three performance psychology-related degrees , including a PhD just didn't work so well in the field and largely what I was taught was based on talk therapy . Sport psychology gets pretty practical .

You learn tools and things like that to teach people . But when I got into the field and started to work with clients and athletes in particular , very high-performing elite people , I learned that those tools didn't work very effectively . That's why I started creating the tools and systems I have and I think and actually if you , that's not just me saying this there are now large sets of data showing that , for all the hype around talk therapy , it is not very effective .

The data shows very clearly . Studies of over 52,000 people shows that CBT , which is the sort of gold standard talk therapy only can be proven to help one in five people . One in five people . And the kicker is those results don't seem to last more than 12 months before people default back to the unhelpful ways of thinking and doing they were before the

Why Traditional Therapy Falls Short

therapy . And why is that the case ? I think there are four core reasons and I want to unpack those . And it goes to some way to explaining why we created a system like we did . Traditional coaching doesn't consider brain states . Most of it doesn't consider the brain at all in the first principle sense .

Even the systems that say they're neuroscience based , I'm very dubious as to what they mean by that . What is understood ? It doesn't strike that they operate from a first principle model about how brains work , and that's completely understandable because we've only been able to look inside brains for about 25 years now . I was very lucky at the start of my education that that's what I began to learn about off the bat , so to speak .

So if we want to be successful , we've got to understand our brain states and get brain state intelligent . And that's why , in our four-step success cycle which we talk people through in train your brain for the AI revolution , we show you how to measure your brain states to start with , and you get a score .

You get a human AI readiness brain state score . And the next reason , then , that I think traditional approaches talk therapy based approaches are failing people is because people are more overwhelmed than ever . The world is more

Your own coaching team, helping you achieve more.

Four Core Reasons for Success

complex . Ai is making it even more complex and they tend to um , when you learn how to coach using a cbt talk therapy based model , you really get taught to focus on tools and tactics , which sometimes people call tips and tricks , and they make sense when you're taught them and people agree it would be a good idea to do that thing to help them to be a better leader or be a better team member or manage stress better so they can sleep at night .

But people quickly forget them and often those tips and tricks are not part of a bigger strategic approach for the individual . You all , we all , know that and understand that businesses have strategies , they have strategic plans , they have long-term strategic plans and short-term strategic plans , and what we've learned is that if you , if you , if you're an individual and you're trying to be at your best , and you don't have a long-term strategic plan and a short-term strategic plan , the likelihood is you're going to struggle .

So that's why in steps three and four of the success cycle so sorry , steps two and three of the success cycle step two is the , the task director system and step three is the day designer system . These are essentially ways to develop your own strategic plan for your future self , but also for today and the next 24 hours .

And then , once you have those strategic plans , any tools that you're using or that you learn to use and you know , in our own approach , we have I think we have about well , nearly 40 tools now . Actually , those tools are more powerful because they're part of a strategic approach to being healthy , happy at your best

Creating Your Strategic Success Plan

in the AI era . And again , when you're just doing normal coaching and people tell us this , they tell us I don't think there's one person we've worked with who hasn't tried coaching before ? And they always tell us I've tried this before , but your stuff works and the other stuff doesn't work . People very nice , they're very , very friendly , but and I thought it was going to help me but it didn't but this is , and that's because we're taking into consideration the brain in a friendly way brain states , we're helping people to create the long-term strategy plan and then the daily strategy plan using our task director system and our day designer system .

And then the final step and this is where traditional approaches this bit often just doesn't exist . And if it does exist , it has no level of sophistication . Um , it's . You need a way of automating your approach , your behaviors , in other words your habits , so that you don't just do them once or twice , you make them as automatic as the unhelpful behaviors were .

And this is why you need a comprehensive understanding of , of behavioral science , not just nudge theory . That's just one ninth of what explains why we do what we do , not just skin as reward and penalty systems again , that's one ninth not just carol dwight , mindset ideas , and I could go on but all of these big behavioral science theories that people trumpet as the answer are actually part of a jigsaw puzzle and we've learned that the jigsaw puzzle has nine parts and that's what our nine action factor system represents .

It's like a bridge between . It gives you literally a bridge between where you are now and where you want to be . Um , and in our success cycle , in train your brain for the air revolution

Ready to perform at your best?

Start for free, take your assessment, start working with your coaching team